Myra Hindley: “The Most Evil Woman in Britain”
Introduction
Myra Hindley (1942–2002) was an English serial killer who, together with her partner Ian Brady, carried out the Moors Murders in the early 1960s. The pair abducted, sexually assaulted, and murdered five children and teenagers, burying several of their bodies on Saddleworth Moor near Manchester. Hindley became one of Britain’s most reviled offenders, emblematic of female participation in sadistic child murder.
Early Life and Background
Hindley was born on 23 July 1942 in Gorton, Manchester, into a working‑class family marked by poverty, instability, and violence. Her father, a laborer and ex‑soldier, was reportedly physically abusive and encouraged toughness and retaliation in his daughter, reinforcing an association between authority, violence, and emotional control.
As a child, she was temporarily sent to live with her grandmother, which provided some stability but also reinforced a sense of emotional dislocation from her immediate family. She left school at 15, working as a junior clerk and later as a typist and receptionist, and by her late teens she was described as outwardly ordinary, socially functional, and capable at work.
Before meeting Brady, Hindley was engaged to a local young man, Ronnie Sinclair, but broke off the engagement, later framing her decision as a rejection of a conventional life in favor of something more intense and “exciting.” This desire for excitement and a more extreme identity would become important in understanding how she responded to Brady’s influence.
Relationship with Ian Brady
Hindley met Ian Brady in 1961 when they both worked at Millwards, a chemical distribution company in Manchester; she as a typist, he as a stock clerk. She was immediately drawn to his aloof, intellectual, and rebellious persona, even though he initially showed little interest in her.
Over time she pursued him, and the relationship that formed was intense and insular. Brady steeped her in his interests: Nazi ideology, sadistic pornography, and writings that glorified power and cruelty. According to psychological analyses, Hindley was emotionally insecure, searching for identity, and highly motivated by Brady’s approval; his dominance and certainty appealed to her need for structure and validation.
As the relationship progressed, Hindley’s appearance, language, and attitudes changed. She dyed her hair blonde, adopted a harder persona, and embraced Brady’s contempt for conventional morality. While Hindley later claimed she was dominated and coerced, many analysts argue the dynamic was one of coercive control and active complicity: she adapted herself to Brady’s fantasies, found excitement in the transgression, and became an essential partner in predatory crime rather than a passive puppet.
The Moors Murders: Victims and Crimes
Between July 1963 and October 1965, Brady and Hindley abducted and murdered five young victims:
- Pauline Reade (16) – July 1963
- John Kilbride (12) – November 1963
- Keith Bennett (12) – June 1964
- Lesley Ann Downey (10) – December 1964
- Edward Evans (17) – October 1965
Several of the victims were sexually assaulted, tortured, and killed, with bodies buried on Saddleworth Moor. The crimes combined sexual sadism, deliberate psychological cruelty, and calculated use of Hindley’s presence as camouflage to gain access to children who would have feared Brady alone.
Hindley’s Role and Modus Operandi
Hindley was far more than an accessory; she was central to luring victims and facilitating Brady’s violence.
Using Trust and Deception
Hindley’s role often involved approaching children in public places, using her status as an apparently respectable young woman to lower their defenses:
- With John Kilbride, she approached the 12‑year‑old at a market and asked him to help carry boxes to her car, promising a ride home.
- With Keith Bennett, she asked for help loading items into her vehicle, then drove him toward the moors where Brady met them.
Children and parents alike were more likely to trust her, making her the “camouflage” Brady needed to enact his fantasies. Without Hindley, it is doubtful Brady could easily have persuaded children to accompany a lone adult male into an isolated landscape.
Transport and Burial
Hindley drove victims to Saddleworth Moor in her car while Brady followed on his motorcycle or joined them en route. After Brady raped, tortured, and killed the victims—usually out of sight of the road—Hindley helped bury the bodies in shallow graves on the moor, sometimes marking the locations with visual cues such as specific rocks or landmarks.
In Pauline Reade’s case, Hindley claimed she waited in the car while Brady took the girl to the moor, where he raped, beat, stabbed, and almost decapitated her; Hindley later helped him bury Reade’s body and her high‑heeled shoes.
Direct Participation in Abuse
The murder of 10‑year‑old Lesley Ann Downey is especially revealing of Hindley’s active involvement. Downey was abducted from a fairground and taken to Hindley’s home, where she was undressed, bound, and subjected to prolonged sexual and psychological torment.
A reel‑to‑reel audio recording captured the assault and Downey’s screams, with both Brady’s and Hindley’s voices audible as the child begged for mercy. Photographs were also taken of the terrified, bound child. Downey was then murdered – likely strangled with string or cord – and her body later buried naked on the moor with her clothes at her feet.
Hindley later tried to minimize her involvement, claiming she was in another room or ran a bath and returned to find Downey dead, but the tape evidence clearly places her in the room, engaging with the victim. This undermines any claim that she was an unwilling bystander.
Arrest and Trial
The murders came to light after the killing of Edward Evans in October 1965.
Brady brought 17‑year‑old Edward Evans back to the house he shared with Hindley in Hattersley. Hindley’s teenage brother‑in‑law, David Smith, was invited to the house; he later witnessed Brady beating Evans to death with an axe in the living room while Hindley allegedly assisted or remained present.
Terrified and horrified, Smith helped Brady and Hindley wrap the body and move it to a spare room, but after returning home he told his wife (Hindley’s sister) and then contacted the police.
Police searched the house and property, finding evidence that linked Brady and Hindley to Evans’s murder and, eventually, to the disappearances of other children. Among the evidence were photographs, the audio recording of Downey’s torture, and items belonging to missing victims.
Brady and Hindley were arrested and charged. Their trial began on 27 April 1966.
They were charged with:
- The murders of Lesley Ann Downey, John Kilbride, and Edward Evans.
- Hindley was additionally charged with harboring Brady in the knowledge that he had killed John Kilbride.
Both pleaded not guilty. After a trial lasting several weeks, the jury found:
- Brady guilty of the murders of Downey, Kilbride, and Evans.
- Hindley guilty of the murders of Downey and Evans and of harboring Brady after Kilbride’s murder.
The death penalty for murder had been abolished in England during the time they were held, so both were sentenced to life imprisonment – the maximum available penalty.
In 1987, after years in prison, Brady and Hindley finally admitted their responsibility for the murders of Pauline Reade and Keith Bennett, whose bodies had been unaccounted for during the 1960s investigations. Reade’s remains were later found on Saddleworth Moor, while Keith Bennett’s body has never been recovered despite extensive searches.
Imprisonment, Appeals, and Death
Hindley spent the remainder of her life in prison. Over the years she launched multiple appeals and campaigns for parole, attempting to reframe herself as rehabilitated and, at times, as a victim of Brady’s influence.
She converted to Roman Catholicism, undertook educational courses, and sought support from public figures and campaigners who argued she had changed; however, public opinion remained overwhelmingly hostile, and the British press repeatedly labeled her “the most evil woman in Britain.”
Successive Home Secretaries made statements that effectively ruled out her release, and judicial reviews upheld whole‑life tariffs for her and Brady.
Myra Hindley died in custody on 15 November 2002 at the age of 60, following respiratory failure due to heart disease. She never left prison.
Psychological Profile and Dynamics with Brady
Hindley’s psychology has been intensely debated, in part because she was a rare female participant in serial child murder and because she later tried to recast her role.
Vulnerability and Agency
Psychological commentaries suggest that Hindley entered adulthood emotionally insecure, with a strong need for external approval and a desire to escape a mundane life; Brady’s confidence, ideological intensity, and cruelty offered a perverse form of structure and identity. She proved willing to reshape herself to meet his expectations and to participate in increasingly extreme behavior as a way to secure her place in the relationship.
However, many analysts argue that her vulnerability does not erase her agency. She actively lured children, participated in their abuse, lied to families, and maintained silence for decades. Her voice on the Downey tape, calmly interacting with a terrified child, contradicts any portrayal of her as merely terrified or coerced.
Some commentators conclude that Hindley derived sexual or emotional gratification from the murders, influenced by Brady’s satisfaction and the thrill of transgression. Others emphasize her apparent self‑centeredness, coldness, and readiness to deceive, suggesting significant narcissistic and callous traits even if no formal personality disorder diagnosis was recorded.
Coercive Control vs Shared Sadism
Modern concepts of coercive control describe relationships in which a dominant partner uses psychological manipulation, isolation, and ideology to erode the other’s moral boundaries over time. Hindley’s relationship with Brady shows many of these features: he provided a worldview that glorified dominance and cruelty, dismissed conventional morality, and tested her “blind allegiance” through increasingly extreme acts.
Yet the pattern of her actions – proactive luring, logistical facilitation, participation in torment, long‑term concealment, and later self‑serving narratives – supports the view that she was not simply brainwashed but embraced the role of co‑offender. The most defensible reading is that coercive control and shared sadism co‑existed: Brady provided the ideology and initial push, Hindley chose to embrace it and became indispensable to its execution.
Legacy
The Moors Murders left a deep scar on British cultural memory. The combination of child victims, sexual sadism, the haunting moorland burial sites, and the involvement of a woman as an active participant has kept the case in the public consciousness for decades.
Hindley’s name became synonymous with female evil, raising enduring questions about how far love, coercion, ideology, and personal pathology can push someone into atrocities – and where vulnerability ends and responsibility begins.
FOR READERS FASCINATED BY CRIMINAL MINDS
From the creators of Violent Minds comes Murder.net - a psychological cyber-thriller about control, fear, and obsession, where a killer streams his murders online to paying subscribers. How far would you go to stop a monster?
Get The Book
