Richard Speck: The 1966 Chicago Nurse Murders’
Introduction
Richard Benjamin Speck (December 6, 1941 – December 5, 1991) was an American mass murderer who committed one of the most shocking crimes in modern criminal history. On the night of July 13-14, 1966, Speck brutally killed eight student nurses in Chicago-a crime that sent shockwaves across the nation and ushered in a contemporary era of mass murder awareness.
Early Life and Family Background
Speck’s life was marked by instability and trauma that set the trajectory toward violence. Born in Kirkwood, Illinois, to Benjamin Franklin Speck and Mary Margaret Carbaugh, Richard was the seventh of eight children in a large religious Baptist family. His father, to whom he was closely attached, died of a heart attack when Richard was only six years old. This loss devastated young Speck and represented the first of many traumatic experiences that would shape his psychology.
In 1951, when Richard was nine years old, his mother remarried and relocated the family to East Dallas, Texas, taking only Richard and his younger sister Carolyn with them. This move proved catastrophic for Richard’s development. His stepfather, Carl Lindberg, was a chronically alcoholic, abusive man who frequently told Richard that he hated him and that he was worthless. Unlike his biological father, whom Speck idealized, his stepfather refused to adopt him, reinforcing feelings of rejection and inadequacy. Carl’s physical and verbal abuse created an environment of fear and hostility during Speck’s critical developmental years.
Over the next twelve years, the family moved frequently-relocating to ten different addresses, typically in poor neighborhoods-creating an unstable, transient existence that prevented Speck from establishing consistent friendships or support networks.
Adolescent Difficulties and Educational Struggles
Speck’s adolescence was characterized by increasing social withdrawal and academic failure. He struggled significantly in school, refusing to wear the glasses necessary for reading because of an intense fear of being stared at by classmates. This social anxiety was compounded by severe acne, which intensified his self-consciousness and drove him further into isolation. His teachers recalled that he “seemed sort of lost” and appeared disconnected from academic material, with observers noting they never witnessed him smile.
Academic performance declined progressively. Speck repeated the eighth grade partly due to selective mutism-his refusal to speak in class motivated by paralyzing fear of drawing attention to himself. In autumn 1957, he enrolled in ninth grade at Crozier Technical High School but failed every subject and did not return for the second semester, dropping out in January 1958 after his sixteenth birthday.
At age thirteen, Speck began drinking alcohol, breaking into his stepfather’s liquor cabinet, initiating a pattern of substance abuse that would escalate throughout his life and become intertwined with his violent behavior. The drinking served a coping function, providing temporary relief from the psychological pain and fear generated by his abusive home environment.
Criminal Escalation and Predatory Behavior
Speck’s early criminal record demonstrates a clear escalation in the severity and nature of his offenses, progressing from petty theft to violent sexual assault and murder. After leaving school, he engaged in minor theft and burglary. By the early 1960s, his criminal behavior had intensified significantly.
In November 1962, at age 21, Speck married Shirley Malone, and they had a daughter together, Bobby Lynn. Despite the brief stability marriage appeared to offer, Speck quickly reverted to criminal behavior. In 1963, he was convicted of theft and check fraud, receiving a three-year sentence but being paroled after only sixteen months in January 1965. Within four weeks of his release, he was arrested again for aggravated assault and imprisoned for an additional sixteen months, serving approximately six months before release.
The period immediately preceding the nurse murders reveals an escalating pattern of violence. On April 2, 1966, Speck viciously raped and robbed a 65-year-old woman, Virgil Harris, in her own home. Subsequently, on April 13, 1966, he brutally beat to death Mary Kay Pierce, a barmaid in his local tavern. Police discovered personal effects belonging to Harris in Speck’s vacant hotel room, directly linking him to the rape attack, yet he managed to elude capture.
Simultaneously, law enforcement in neighboring states were seeking to question Speck regarding multiple murders. Indiana authorities wanted to interview him about three young women who disappeared on July 2, 1966, and whose bodies were never recovered. Michigan authorities also sought him for questioning regarding murders of four females aged between 7 and 60 that occurred while his ship was in the vicinity. Despite these investigation, Speck repeatedly evaded law enforcement and “kept police forces guessing.”
The Night of the Murders: July 13-14, 1966
On the evening of July 13, 1966, Speck arrived at 2319 East 100th Street in Chicago’s South Deering neighborhood, a townhouse that served as a dormitory for student nurses employed at the nearby South Chicago Community Hospital. The building housed eight young nurses, all in their early twenties: Gloria Davy, Patricia Matusek, Nina Jo Schmale, Pamela Wilkening, Suzanne Farris, Mary Ann Jordan, Merlita Gargullo, and Valentina Pasion.
When 23-year-old Corazon Amurao, a Filipina exchange student nurse, opened the door in response to Speck’s knock around 11 p.m., he forced his way inside at gunpoint. He immediately told the women he only wanted money and was not going to hurt them-a statement contradicted almost immediately by his actions. Speck forced the women into a bedroom and demanded they empty their purses before he used his knife to bind their hands and feet using strips torn from bedsheets, using nautical knots from his maritime work experience.
Throughout the evening, as more nurses returned home, Speck captured and bound them as well. Around midnight, three additional nurses arrived to find the nightmare already unfolding. By approximately 11:30 p.m., all nine potential victims were imprisoned within the townhouse.
What followed was a systematic, hours-long massacre. Speck led the women out of the room one by one-at intervals of twenty to thirty minutes-murdering each victim individually. The methodology was methodical and brutal: victims were stabbed repeatedly, strangled with bedsheet strips, slashed across the throat, or subjected to combinations of these methods. The last victim, 22-year-old Gloria Davy, was raped before being strangled to death.
The violence persisted for several hours while Corazon Amurao, the sole survivor, hid beneath a bed in the darkness, listening to the muffled screams of her colleagues and friends being murdered. She remained hidden, terrified and immobilized by fear, throughout the entire rampage. Around 3 a.m., exhausted and believing he had killed all of the nurses, Speck stole the money he had originally demanded and departed the townhouse.
Amurao remained under the bed, frozen in terror, for hours after Speck’s departure. Around 6 a.m., gaining courage, she managed to untie herself and crawl to a second-story ledge, where she screamed desperately for help for approximately twenty minutes: “All my friends are dead! I’m the only one alive! Oh, my God! Help, please!” Concerned neighbors summoned police, who arrived to scenes of devastating carnage.
The Investigation and Speck’s Apprehension
Police responding to Amurao’s screams encountered eight brutally murdered young women scattered throughout the townhouse. The crime scene represented unprecedented mass murder in modern American history. The critical breakthrough came from Amurao’s vivid recollection of a distinctive tattoo on Speck’s forearm that read “Born to Raise Hell,”-a detail that would lead directly to his identification and capture.
Police worked with Amurao to construct an Identikit composite sketch, placing both the image and the critical tattoo description on the front page of every local newspaper the next morning. The widespread publicity enabled rapid identification of Speck.
Unaware of the police net closing around him, Speck was drinking heavily in bars across Chicago, attempting to remain undetected. However, two days after the murders, on July 16, 1966, he attempted suicide by slashing his right wrist and left elbow at the seedy dollar-a-night hotel where he was hiding. In what appeared to be a change of heart, he summoned help for himself. Medical personnel took him to Cook County Hospital for emergency surgery to repair severed arteries.
In a moment of ironic justice, his tattoo-the same “Born to Raise Hell” marking that Amurao had memorized-gave him away once again. While Speck was recovering under police observation at the hospital on July 17, 1966, he was positively identified and arrested. A dozen uniformed officers ensured that his history of evasion ended there.
The Trial and Conviction (1967)
Speck’s trial began on April 3, 1967, in Peoria, Illinois, following a change of venue due to the overwhelming publicity and public outrage in Chicago. The trial lasted twelve days and presented overwhelming evidence of guilt. Assistant State Attorney William Martin methodically built the prosecution’s case through witnesses who placed Speck near the nurses’ house before the murders and testified to his drinking binge while brandishing a gun and knife on the day of the crimes.
The trial’s most dramatic and memorable moment came when Corazon Amurao was called to testify. Despite having endured the horrific experience of hiding beneath a bed while her eight colleagues were systematically murdered, Amurao provided calm, composed testimony. When prosecutor Martin asked if she could identify the killer, she stood, walked across the courtroom floor, and confronted Speck directly. With her index finger nearly touching his nose, she stated firmly: “This is the man.” The moment crystallized the jury’s certainty regarding his guilt.
On April 15, 1967, after only 49 minutes of deliberation, the jury returned a guilty verdict on all eight murder counts and recommended the death penalty. Judge Herbert C. Paschen formally sentenced Speck to death on June 6, 1967.
However, Speck’s sentence would be transformed by national legal developments. When the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1972 that capital punishment as then administered constituted cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the Eighth Amendment, Speck’s death sentence was commuted. He was resentenced to eight consecutive terms of life imprisonment with sentences of 50 to 150 years each.
Psychological Evaluations and Psychiatric Testimony
During sentencing hearings, psychiatric testimony revealed significant evidence of Speck’s mental disturbance. Dr. Ner Littner, medical director of a child therapy program in Chicago, testified that while Speck understood the nature of the charges against him and could work with his legal counsel (meeting the legal standard for competency to stand trial), he was nonetheless mentally ill and not responsible for his actions during the murders.
Dr. Littner described Speck as living under severe “mental pressure” at the time of the crimes, noting that a divorce a year prior had left him feeling inadequate, and his distress peaked the day before the murders when he lost a job opportunity on a ship. Additionally, that same day, Speck experienced impotence with a prostitute, leading to escalated drinking and drug use. Dr. Littner concluded that “his resulting antisocial behavior would not have been within his control.”
The psychiatrist outlined that Speck had suffered from mental health issues since age thirteen, with early manifestations appearing at age five when he struck himself on the head with a claw hammer. Dr. Littner identified multiple phobias affecting Speck, including fear of confined spaces, water, snakes, spiders, and being buried alive. Speck reportedly coped with inner turmoil through self-destructive behaviors, including instances where he fell from a tree, collided with a pole, crashed into a parked car while riding a bicycle, broke his leg by stepping in a hole, and sustained injuries fleeing from police.
Another psychiatric expert, Dr. Marvin Kaplan, testified that he believed Speck was brain-damaged as a child from multiple traumatic brain injuries. This doctor argued that when Speck drank and used drugs, the combination of underlying brain damage and psychotropic substances rendered him incapable of controlling his aggression, making him not responsible for the night’s violence.
Post-mortem analysis of Speck’s brain, conducted after his death in 1991, identified abnormalities in the hippocampal formations of the medial temporal lobe-a brain region involved in memory formation and located proximate to the amygdala, which controls mood and aggression. This scientific finding provided objective evidence supporting the psychiatric testimony about neurobiological dysfunction.
The XYY Chromosome Controversy
One of the most sensational aspects of Speck’s case involved initial reports that he possessed an XYY chromosome pattern-an extra Y chromosome theorized by some to predispose individuals to aggression and criminality. This generated significant media attention and scientific discussion about biological determinism in crime. However, subsequent testing conclusively determined that Speck possessed a normal XY chromosome pattern, debunking this theory. The incident highlighted how even erroneous biological claims can capture public imagination during sensational trials.
Prison Life and the Controversial Video (1988)
For twenty-four years following his conviction, Speck served life sentences at Stateville Correctional Center in Crest Hill, Illinois, unsuccessfully petitioning for parole no fewer than seven times. However, in 1988, six years before his death, a videotape was produced inside the prison facility that would reignite public outrage decades later when it was broadcast in 1996.
The video, apparently filmed with video equipment ostensibly kept for guard training purposes, captured Speck engaged in shocking behavior within the maximum-security facility. The footage shows Speck, then approximately 46 years old, cavorting in women’s underwear, engaging in sexual acts with male inmates, and apparently using cocaine. At one point, Speck stripped out of his prison jumpsuit to reveal blue women’s undergarments, and he appeared to have developed ample breast tissue, raising questions about whether he had been covertly supplied with female hormones while in prison.
Most astonishingly, on the video Speck confesses for the first time to murdering the eight student nurses. This constituted a dramatic reversal from his trial testimony, where he claimed ignorance of the murders due to drug-induced amnesia. On camera, Speck arrogantly boasted: “If they only knew how much fun I was having here, they would turn me loose.”
When the video was broadcast nationally on A&E cable in May 1996 by a Chicago television station, it sparked enormous public outrage and legislative hearings in the Illinois State Legislature. Viewers and lawmakers questioned how a mass murderer could enjoy such apparent freedom, access to drugs, and sexual privileges within a supposedly secure correctional facility. State Representative Thomas Johnson asked rhetorically: “Who is minding the store here? How can this stuff go on so that you can even make movies without the system being aware of it?”
The controversy exposed significant failures in prison oversight and security. Questions arose about whether corrections officials were adequately monitoring inmate activities, how contraband drugs entered the facility, and whether the production of video footage could occur undetected within a maximum-security institution.
Death and Legacy
Richard Speck lived just one day short of what would have been his fiftieth birthday. On December 5, 1991, Speck died of a massive heart attack. He had been admitted to Silver Cross Hospital in Joliet, Illinois, the previous evening with severe chest pains. Will County Coroner Duane Krieger reported that an autopsy revealed Speck had significant heart disease.
Speck was cremated, and his ashes were scattered in an undisclosed location. His body, however, was not entirely destroyed. Recognizing the potential scientific value, his brain was preserved for scientific research, while the remainder of his body was cremated.
The Victims: Remembering the Eight
The eight young women murdered by Speck were promising nurses with their entire lives ahead of them. Gloria Davy, Patricia Matusek, Nina Jo Schmale, Pamela Wilkening, Suzanne Farris, Mary Ann Jordan, Merlita Gargullo, and Valentina Pasion-all in their early twenties-were robbed of their futures as caregivers and medical professionals.
Two of the victims, Valentina Pasion and Merlita Gargullo, were exchange students from the Philippines. Their bodies were repatriated following a mass held in their honor in Chicago. The other six victims were American nurses whose deaths devastated their families and the nursing community.
Beyond the eight murdered in the townhouse, one woman whose decisions that evening saved her life deserves recognition. Luisa Silverio, another Filipina nurse who was supposed to sleep over at the townhouse that night, had decided instead to return home to answer letters from her boyfriend. While at home, the hospital called asking if she could pick up a substitute shift the following day-her usual day off. She called Valentina Pasion to inform her she would no longer be sleeping over. When Luisa later returned to the townhouse and found no one answering the door (as Speck was occupied murdering her colleagues upstairs), she eventually departed without entering. That decision, made out of courtesy to answer a boyfriend’s letters and accommodate a substitute shift, inadvertently saved her from sharing the fate of her eight colleagues. Luisa kept quiet about her narrow escape for fifty-four years, fearing it might impact her American dream as a nurse, only sharing her story publicly in 2024.
Corazon Amurao: The Sole Survivor’s Courage
Corazon Amurao, the 23-year-old Filipino exchange nurse who opened the door to Speck on that fateful night, demonstrated extraordinary courage in the aftermath of unimaginable trauma. After hiding beneath a bed while eight colleagues were systematically murdered, she crawled to safety and identified the killer despite multiple lucrative offers from major publications desperate to buy her story.
Life magazine and the Saturday Evening Post made substantial financial offers, with additional offers from Filipino media outlets. The temptation to capitalize on her story was substantial. However, Amurao issued a statement declaring: “It is my desire to make clear that the memory of my dear colleagues is of such character that I do not want to have it tainted by the acceptance by me of money or any other personal benefit.” Though she declined media compensation, she justifiably received a $10,000 reward from South Chicago Community Hospital for her pivotal role in identifying the killer.
Amurao went on to marry, raise children and grandchildren, and build a fulfilling life that honored her murdered colleagues’ memory. She survived not only the physical horror of that night but the psychological trauma of knowing she alone had escaped while eight friends perished in horror.
Historical Significance and Conclusion
Richard Speck’s crimes shocked the American conscience and ushered in contemporary awareness of mass murder as a distinct phenomenon. The case demonstrated the dangers posed by untreated mental illness combined with severe childhood trauma, substance abuse, and inadequate incarceration security. Speck’s eventual confession on the controversial prison video decades later added grotesque irony to a case already marked by profound tragedy.
The case raised enduring questions about criminal psychology, the relationship between childhood abuse and violence, the efficacy of the criminal justice system, and the appropriate treatment of prisoners convicted of heinous crimes. The victims-eight promising young women with their entire futures ahead of them-remain memorialized as a stark reminder of the devastating human cost of unchecked violence.
FOR READERS FASCINATED BY CRIMINAL MINDS
From the creators of Violent Minds comes Murder.net - a psychological cyber-thriller about control, fear, and obsession, where a killer streams his murders online to paying subscribers. How far would you go to stop a monster?
Get The Book
