The Most Common Traits Found in Serial Killers

According to Research

Serial killers have captivated public attention for decades, inspiring countless books, documentaries, and psychological studies. While no single profile fits all serial killers-they exist across the spectrum of intelligence, social class, and background-extensive research has identified consistent patterns of traits, behaviors, and characteristics that appear with striking frequency. Understanding these commonalities provides insight into how these individuals develop and what warning signs may indicate future violent behavior.

Psychological and Personality Traits

Extreme Antisocial Behavior and Lack of Empathy

The most consistent psychological feature among serial killers is extreme antisocial behavior. They tend to lack empathy, appear incapable of remorse, show no regard for laws or social norms, and demonstrate a strong desire to revenge themselves against individuals or society at large by carrying out violent acts.

Research analyzing personality traits of serial killers found that impulsivity, lack of empathy, and aggression significantly prevail among this population. These traits don’t exist in isolation but form part of a complex structure of emotional imbalance, social and educational influences, and neurobiological mechanisms.

Serial killers demonstrate disrupted connections between emotional filters and action control. They experience inconsistent affective levels and extreme oscillations in emotional states. This affective immaturity resides in a cleavage between cognitive and affective processes, with emotional responses disproportionately dominating rational thought.

Many serial killers show no signs of remorse or guilt for their actions. Even when confronted with overwhelming evidence, they display no genuine regret. This profound lack of conscience allows them to commit horrific acts without the internal barriers that prevent most people from harming others.

Psychopathy: The Core Trait

Approximately 85% of serial killers are psychopaths. Psychopathy is characterized by superficial charm, manipulativeness, grandiose self-perception, pathological lying, lack of empathy and remorse, and shallow emotional responses.

The defining characteristics include:

Demonstrating no boundaries or regard for the rights of others
Having no ability to distinguish between right and wrong
No signs of remorse or empathy when they’ve done something wrong
Repeated or pathological lying
Manipulating or harming others, especially for personal gain
Repeatedly breaking the law with no remorse
No regard for rules around safety or personal responsibility
Strong self-love or narcissism
Quick to anger or overly sensitive when criticized
Displaying superficial charm that quickly disappears when things aren’t going their way

Research using brain imaging reveals that psychopaths show reduced connections between the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and the amygdala. This dysfunction in crucial social-emotional circuitry represents a stable characteristic, explaining why psychopaths process emotions differently than neurotypical individuals.

The Dark Triad: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and Psychopathy

Many serial killers exhibit all three components of the Dark Triad-a particularly dangerous combination.

Narcissism in serial killers manifests as:

Grandiose sense of self-importance (exaggerating achievements and talents)
Preoccupation with fantasies of unlimited success, power, and brilliance
Need for admiration and validation
Sense of entitlement
Lack of empathy (though they can “fake” it when needed)
Fragile self-esteem masked by arrogance

Ted Bundy exemplified grandiose narcissism-charming, manipulative, seeing himself as superior. He displayed grandiose self-worth (defending himself in court), need for admiration (enjoying media attention), sense of entitlement, interpersonal exploitation, and lack of empathy. Dennis Rader (BTK) craved attention and recognition, sending taunting letters to police and media.

Research indicates most serial and mass murderers suffer from a pathologized form of narcissism. The killer’s megalomania manifests when claiming to possess higher knowledge and morality, viewing himself as a special being and victims as “chosen”.

Machiavellianism involves manipulative, deceitful, and strategic behavior aimed at personal gain. Serial killers displaying this trait are patient, strategic manipulators who view others as pawns, engage in strategic planning, and execute calculated predatory aggression.

Individuals high in all three traits are often the most dangerous, combining cold detachment (psychopathy), manipulation (Machiavellianism), and a grandiose sense of self (narcissism).

Behavioral Warning Signs and Early Indicators

Predatory Behavior: Stalking and Victim Selection

The most common serial killer trait is predatory behavior. Serial killers often stalk their victims or act on impulse when they see potential targets. Many go through distinct phases starting with fantasizing about murder, with each fantasy becoming more sexually charged until the killer forms a dependency on it.

After the first murder, killers may form a ritual of stalking victims, committing murder, and often keeping tokens or trophies. These can include photographs, jewelry, underwear, or even body parts. Trophy collection serves as a means of extending the “high” from the kill and allows them to relive the experience.

Dennis Rader would watch women for long periods before striking to learn about their comings and goings, family connections, neighborhood activity, and best times to attack. This covert surveillance helps killers identify potential targets and develop strategies to gain entry undetected.

Voyeurism and Peeping Tom Behavior

Research reveals a striking pattern: many of America’s most notorious serial killers-Ted Bundy, suspected Golden State Killer Joseph DeAngelo, Dennis Rader (BTK), Derrick Todd Lee, and Phillip Hughes-all engaged in voyeurism during their teen and early adult years.

Voyeurism represents part of a natural evolution of criminal activity for developing serial killers. Burgeoning killers must overcome societal barriers against harming others, often beginning with acts that have less significant social consequences. Someone may begin as a Peeping Tom before escalating to entering homes while unoccupied to steal underwear or other sexually arousing items.

Spying on unsuspecting victims provides several advantages for violent predators:

Gains a sense of power and control by putting victims “in their sights”
Allows them to feel empowered and strong before they’re ready to kill
Part of the maturation process of a fledgling serial killer
Fulfills sexual fantasies (many masturbate while peeping)
Provides practical training on how to isolate people, watch people, and enter houses

Criminologist Scott Bonn, who corresponded extensively with Rader, noted: “When he was stationed in the Army in Germany, he would break and enter and break into women’s apartments and steal their underwear”. For many, there’s a strong sexual component to these voyeuristic acts.

Former FBI profiler Brad Garrett called peeping a “training ground” for serial killers: “The idea that Ted Bundy was involved in peeping makes sense because it’s basically a training ground about how you isolate people, how you watch people, how you get into houses”.

Not all Peeping Toms become killers, but becoming a Peeping Tom is “a very logical and natural stage in the progression of a fledgling future serial killer”.

Superficial Charm and Manipulation

Psychopaths excel at creating an appealing facade. They use charm to disarm others and gain trust quickly. Their charisma can be magnetic, drawing people in effortlessly. This superficial charm serves as a powerful tool for manipulation.

Ted Bundy presented himself as intelligent and likable, fooling both victims and legal professionals. He used his charm and good looks to lure victims, often feigning injury to gain sympathy. Once he gained their trust, he would abduct, assault, and kill them in brutal ways.

The charm is carefully tailored to each target, adapting to individual preferences and vulnerabilities. A psychopath may shower someone with flattery and gifts or present themselves as the perfect listener, creating an illusion of deep connection. This calculated approach allows them to quickly form bonds and lower others’ defenses.

However, this charm lacks depth and sincerity, serving only as a means to an end. Psychopathic serial killers can identify vulnerable and passive victims-including females, children, and elderly seniors-using their superficial charm and glibness to win affection by pretending to be compassionate, loving carers.

The Need for Power and Control

The need for control represents a significant trait seen among serial killers. According to research, controlling and dominating their victims is a serial killer’s primary motive-murder is empowering. They are able to control what their victims do, how long they live, and how they die.

This obsession with control manifests in multiple ways:

Many serial killers are predators who can be secretive and deceptive, actively searching for victims
They imagine their crimes in advance and enact them in the real world to activate mental reward mechanisms
They are often self-delusional

The decision-making power over life and death infuses feelings of omnipotence. When delusional fantasies reach their peak, killers feel compelled to enact them, dominating victims and transforming them into objects for pleasure.

Many serial killers feel sexual arousal when plotting and executing murder. Rape is often involved because it’s a way for the killer to feel in control-outside this situation, a victim would likely reject sexual advances, but when the killer is in control, they don’t fear rejection.

Childhood Warning Signs and Developmental Patterns

The Macdonald Triad: A Controversial Framework

The Macdonald Triad-comprising animal cruelty, fire-setting, and bedwetting-was proposed in 1963 as predictive of future violent behavior. However, extensive research has revealed significant limitations in its predictive validity.

While these behaviors appear with some frequency in serial killer backgrounds, they are not reliable predictors of serial murder. The triad behaviors are better understood as products of psychological and physical parental abuse-children subjected to traumatic experiences need outlets where they can preserve autonomy and control.

Animal Cruelty

This represents one of the strongest warning signs. Children who torture or kill small animals like squirrels, birds, cats, and dogs without showing remorse are highly likely to be sociopaths. Many serial killers kill to control others’ lives, and as children, small animals are the only lives they have power to control.

Serial killers generally seek control over the life of another, and at a younger age, a small animal is easiest to fully dominate. Any adolescent who displays this activity is at extreme risk of developing into a serial killer when they reach adulthood.

Jeffrey Dahmer killed several animals, including a jar of tadpoles after giving them to his teacher, and would dissect roadkill and bleach their bones. Ted Bundy manipulated and killed pet store mice. John Wayne Gacy allegedly set wild turkeys on fire with gasoline.

Fire-Setting

While it may be common for young people to enjoy the sight of fire, a psychopath’s interest borders on potential arson. They will set anything they can on fire just to destroy it. This behavior represents an outlet for anger and a way to exert destructive power.

Bedwetting (Enuresis)

Bedwetting beyond age 5, particularly past age 12, appears with notable frequency in serial killer backgrounds. However, the connection is more complex than originally believed.

Bedwetting can be genetic. It can also be a sign of trauma or neglect. If you accept that many sociopaths are stuck in an infancy stage of psychosocial development (per Erik Erikson’s theory), it would not be difficult to associate bedwetting as a trait, as toilet training is generally paired with later stages of development that were never addressed.

The overwhelming majority of children who experience childhood trauma, neglect, and bedwetting do not become serial killers. Childhood trauma and neglect are very often part of a serial killer’s childhood, but not universally.

Social Isolation and Withdrawal

Serial killers frequently exhibit pronounced social isolation and withdrawal during childhood and adolescence.

Jeffrey Dahmer was described as quiet and socially isolated in school. He struggled to form meaningful relationships and often engaged in bizarre behavior to gain attention, such as faking seizures or mimicking people with disabilities. His social withdrawal, interest in dead animals, substance abuse, and disturbed fantasies went largely unnoticed or unaddressed by adults.

Compared to other perpetrators, socially isolated individuals who become violent offenders are significantly more likely to be unemployed, single, childless, and sexually frustrated; to have mental health problems; to use substances; and to show interest in past violence.

Experts point to early life social isolation as a case study in the intersection of neglect and emerging psychopathy. While not exhibiting overt aggression toward people as children, emotional detachment and fascination with death represent significant red flags.

Childhood Trauma and Abuse

On average, 50% of serial killers report experiencing psychological abuse, 36% physical abuse, and 26% sexual abuse. Childhood abuse is significantly more prevalent in certain serial killer typologies, with the type of abuse influencing later victim choice and behavior.

In a study of 62 male serial killers, 48% had been rejected as children by a parent or important figure. This rejection often represents a turning point, as these future killers began diving into self-indulgent fantasies and struggled to understand themselves during puberty.

Physical, sexual, and psychological abuse and emotional deprivation establish foundations for future criminal behavior. The social experiences that make people dangerous violent criminals are significant traumatic experiences rather than trivial ones.

Head Injuries

Approximately 80% of high-profile serial killers have suffered significant brain injuries, particularly during critical developmental periods. Head injuries in childhood and adolescence are remarkably common among serial killers, ranging from ordinary concussions to skull fractures and serious injuries.

The timing matters enormously-brain injuries before age 5 permanently disrupt development of foundational brain structures, while injuries during adolescence alter existing behavior and impair impulse control and judgment.

Cognitive and Intellectual Characteristics

Intelligence: Dispelling the Genius Myth

Contrary to popular belief, serial killers are not uniformly highly intelligent. The average serial killer has an IQ of 94.5-slightly below the average person’s IQ of 95-105.

Research on 202 serial killers found:

Median IQ: 89.0
Mean IQ: 95.1
Lowest: 57 (Simon Pirela)
Highest: 165 (Theodore Kaczynski, the Unabomber)

Intelligence varies significantly by serial killer type:

Organized killers: Mean IQ = 99.6
Disorganized killers: Mean IQ = 93.2
Bombers: Mean IQ = 140.3
Those who bludgeon victims: Mean IQ = 86.3

Serial killers motivated by enjoyment have higher average IQs (100.4) than those motivated by financial gain (90.9). Method of killing also correlates with intelligence-those who use bombs have significantly higher IQs than those using other methods.

While some serial killers like Ted Bundy (high intelligence), Jeffrey Dahmer (IQ 145), and Andrew Cunanan (IQ 147) were exceptionally intelligent, others like Henry Lee Lucas (IQ 85), Fred West (IQ 84), and Ottis Toole (IQ 75) scored significantly below average.

The distribution of IQ levels among serial killers does not model that of the normal population, with statistically significant differences in intelligence relative to methodological approach and motivations.

Fantasy Life and Compulsive Behavior

Many serial killers have an elaborate fantasy life. They imagine their crimes in advance and enact them in the real world to activate their mental reward mechanisms. They are often self-delusional.

Fantasy serves as the drive mechanism for repetitive acts of violence. During developmental periods, serial killers process highly developed fantasy systems to defend against traumatic reality they cannot accept. As adults, these fantasies allow them to relive trauma with roles reversed-no longer the passive victim but the active aggressor.

With fantasy progression, the virtual world becomes insufficient and the serial murderer needs to transform fantasy into reality. The act of murder solidifies and reinforces the fantasy. Just as drug addiction requires increasing doses, serial killers require increasingly frequent murders as fantasies strengthen.

After the first murder, the killer activates a “cyclical mechanism,” entering a circular complex mental process like addiction, leading them to kill again. All serial killers follow this pattern, increasing the frequency of their killings. By this time, there are no remaining internal forces that will stop the serial killer’s actions.

Ritualistic and Compulsive Patterns

A peculiar element of serial murder is ritual. The subject is forced by internal fantasies to follow a constant repetitive pattern over time in some or all phases-for example, choosing the same type of victim and arranging the corpse always in a certain way.

The subject is obliged to respect a certain ritual order which is necessary to represent their inner world in real life. This is a compulsive behavior fueled by impossible desires. With the passage of time and progression of homicides, they develop a true syndrome of habituation and addiction that leads them to always seek higher levels of violence.

Serial killing represents an imprinted and fixed action pattern. Just as animals imprint certain behavioral patterns, serial killers imprint on specific victim archetypes. Early experiences shape violent fantasies via imprinting, making ritualized killing compulsive.

The dopamine-opiate system reinforces serial killer behaviors, triggering dopamine highs akin to the thrill of tracking prey. Many engage in trophy collection, a behavior that mirrors territorial marking in dominant predators.

Emotional and Interpersonal Characteristics

Emotional Immaturity and Instability

Affective immaturity is often another characteristic within serial killers, residing in a cleavage between cognitive and affective processes with a stronger proportion of the latter. Emotional lack of maturity leads to psychological stiffness and disrupted reactions in order to obtain pleasure in a non-realistic mode.

Serial killers are capable of intense reactions as responses to lowest provocations, reflecting frustrations accumulated during childhood and adolescence stages from parental disapproval and rejection by social groups.

The Inferiority Complex

The inferior complex of the criminal is usually structured on four levels:

Egocentrism: Tendency to report every aspect of the outer and inner environment to oneself, being the center of all situations and possibilities. The egocentric person cannot see beyond their own desires and needs and can become dominant and despotic to obtain what they want.
Lability: Oscillation of emotional levels. The labile person is highly suggestible, easily influenced, and responds with impaired emotional acts.
Aggression: When it becomes a constant behavior, almost like a professional feature, manifesting constantly and consciously.
Affective indifference: Strongly related to egocentrism, coming in parallel with poor moral principles. This represents the individual’s incapacity to understand the pain and needs of others. They are incapable of empathy and emotional exteriorization, which makes them low-responsive to psychotherapy.

Serial killers have low self-esteem because of physical handicaps or psychological trauma inside the family. As such, they blame society and refuse to insert themselves. The crime scene is usually chaotic as they wear inner psychological tension based on frustrations.

Deceit and Pathological Lying

Psychopaths excel at pathological lying due to their lack of emotional investment in truth-telling. They can maintain complex deceptions without experiencing stress or guilt. Their impaired insight into their own behavior allows them to lie convincingly-they may believe their own fabrications, making deception appear effortless.

Other forms of control include deceit and manipulation. Ted Bundy manipulated victims by pretending to have a disability or injury requiring a cast. Once he had manipulated victims into vulnerable situations, he would rape and murder them.

Patterns of lying, aggressiveness, failure to conform to social norms, and irresponsibility characterize antisocial personality disorder, which is extremely common among serial killers.

Behavioral Instability

Job Instability and Authority Issues

Serial killers often demonstrate trouble keeping jobs long-term. They quit or get fired frequently because they’re impulsive, manipulative, or struggle with authority, routine, or basic human interaction.

Their resumes look less like a career ladder and more like a crime scene timeline. Sometimes it’s a pattern of instability, or worse, it’s a mask that blends into society just long enough to strike again.

Obsessive Note-Taking

Serial killers love control and really need it. Obsessive note-taking or journaling appears with notable frequency. While journaling can be therapeutic for most people, when the notebook sounds less like a therapy tool and more like an unedited confession, it becomes a red flag.

Night Owl Behavior

There’s staying up late because you’re stressed or addicted to your phone, and then there’s the 3:00 a.m. lurker who sits in complete darkness with no TV, no music, just thinking. Some serial killers exhibit pronounced night owl behavior with no clear explanation, potentially using darkness to plan or ruminate on violent fantasies.

Obsessive Cleaning

Serial killers with obsessive cleaning habits aren’t just neat freaks but “erasers”-meticulous cleaners and crime scene vanishers. Their spotless counters and perfectly aligned remotes aren’t about aesthetics, it’s about control. In some very dark cases, it’s a red flag with bloodstains-they’re practicing erasing evidence.

Sensation Seeking and Risk-Taking

Some research suggests serial killers may display sensation-seeking tendencies. The sensation-seeker’s desire for novel and stimulating experiences drives them to seek out “sensational” events. High sensation-seekers pursue intense or novel stimulation because they are generally under-aroused compared to their optimal cortical arousal level.

Games of chance sometimes attract risk-taking offenders. Serial killers like Rodney Alcala appeared on “The Dating Game” in 1978-right in the middle of his killing spree. This suggests certain offenders are drawn to public attention and risk-taking scenarios despite the danger of exposure.

The arousal from ostensibly negative emotions becomes positively reinforcing if it elevates the individual to their optimal level of cortical arousal. High sensation-seekers may habituate more quickly to repeated exposure to stimulating stimuli, prompting them to seek out novel experiences to evade the inevitable decrease in arousal that comes with familiarity.

The Morbid Fascination Component

Many serial killers demonstrate fascination with death and morbid interests from an early age.

Jeffrey Dahmer‘s early fascination with death, social isolation, emotional neglect, and emergence of paraphilic tendencies created a dangerous psychological profile. His progression from a disturbed child to a methodical serial killer exemplifies the tragic consequences of overlooked behavioral warning signs.

Serial killers often exhibit morbid fascination as part of their psychological makeup. This fascination with the macabre, with death, and with exerting control over life represents a core element of their personality structure.

Conclusion: No Single Profile, But Consistent Patterns

While there is no single profile that fits all serial killers-they vary tremendously in intelligence, background, methodology, and motivation-research has identified remarkably consistent patterns of traits and behaviors.

The most reliable indicators include:

Psychological traits: Extreme antisocial behavior, lack of empathy and remorse, psychopathy (85% of serial killers), narcissism, manipulativeness, and pathological lying

Behavioral patterns: Predatory behavior, voyeurism and stalking, need for power and control, superficial charm, fantasy development, ritualistic compulsions, and trophy collecting

Childhood warning signs: Animal cruelty, fire-setting, social isolation, childhood trauma and abuse (50% psychological, 36% physical, 26% sexual), head injuries (80%), and bedwetting

Cognitive characteristics: Average to slightly below-average intelligence (mean IQ 94.5), though with significant variation; elaborate fantasy lives; and compulsive, ritualistic thinking

Emotional patterns: Emotional immaturity, lability, egocentrism, affective indifference, low self-esteem masked by grandiosity, and inability to form genuine emotional connections

Early behavioral red flags: Voyeurism, job instability, obsessive behaviors, morbid fascinations, sensation-seeking, and escalating boundary violations

Understanding these traits serves multiple purposes. For law enforcement, these patterns inform criminal profiling and investigative strategies. For mental health professionals, they highlight risk factors that might enable earlier intervention. For the general public, they dispel myths (serial killers aren’t all geniuses) while providing realistic awareness of warning signs.

However, it’s critical to note that many individuals display some of these traits without ever becoming violent offenders. These characteristics exist on spectra, and their convergence in specific combinations under particular environmental conditions appears necessary for serial killing to develop.

The most dangerous individuals are those who combine multiple Dark Triad traits (psychopathy, narcissism, Machiavellianism), experienced significant childhood trauma, suffered neurological damage, developed elaborate violent fantasies, and possess the organizational capacity to plan and execute murders while evading detection.

Research continues to refine our understanding of these traits and their interactions, contributing to better prevention, identification, and intervention strategies. While we may never fully predict who will become a serial killer, recognizing these common patterns brings us closer to that goal.

SHARE TWEET