Violent Minds

Why Some People Enjoy Causing Pain

For most people, inflicting suffering on others produces guilt, remorse, and distress. But for a disturbing minority, cruelty is pleasurable, exciting, and rewarding. They don’t harm others reluctantly as a means to an end, but actively seek out opportunities to cause pain because the suffering itself is gratifying. Understanding sadism and torture psychology requires examining a complex intersection of neurobiology, personality traits, childhood trauma, and the mechanics of pleasure and control. This comprehensive analysis explores why some humans derive satisfaction from inflicting pain, how sadistic tendencies develop, and what distinguishes everyday sadists from dangerous predators.

Defining Sadism: Beyond Fantasies and Deviance

The Clinical Picture

Sadism, derived from the Marquis de Sade, encompasses sexual and non-sexual pleasure derived from inflicting pain, humiliation, or suffering on others.

Key Characteristics of Sadism:

• Experience of pleasure from others’ pain or humiliation
• Tendency to derive satisfaction from witnessing suffering
• Fascination with violence and physical harm
• Lack of empathy or diminished empathic response
• Desire for control and dominance over others
• Often combines with dehumanization of victims

Sexual Sadism vs. Everyday Sadism:

Sexual Sadism Disorder: Diagnostically rare, affecting only 1-2% of the population. Involves recurrent, intense sexually arousing fantasies about inflicting psychological or physical suffering. Often chronic and escalating in severity over the lifespan.

Everyday Sadism: Much more common in the general population. Encompasses non-sexual pleasure from cruelty, humiliation, or witnessing suffering. Manifests in bullying, internet trolling, violence in video games, or simply enjoying someone else’s misfortune.

Critical Finding: Sadistic tendencies exist on a spectrum and are found in many “normal” people, not just violent criminals.

How Sadists Differ from Psychopaths

The Crucial Distinction

While often conflated, sadists and psychopaths represent distinct psychological profiles with different motivations.

Psychopaths:

• Lack genuine empathy and emotional connection
• Engage in harm primarily to achieve desired goals
• View violence as a means to an end (money, power, sex)
• Act with calculated self-interest
• May harm but don’t necessarily enjoy suffering itself
• Lack remorse not because they’re sadistic but because they lack conscience

Sadists:

• Feel others’ pain more intensely than average
• Actively derive pleasure from causing that pain
• May inflict harm at personal cost, simply to cause suffering
• Experience intrinsic motivation to inflict suffering
• Motivation is distinct from achieving external goals
• Paradoxically feel remorse afterward (once victim’s suffering has ceased)

The Overlap: Psychopathy and sadism correlate, but psychopathy is not sufficient for sadism, and sadism is not necessary for psychopathy.

What Makes Sadism Unique: The willingness to invest extra time and effort to cause suffering to innocent people, even at personal cost, distinguishes sadism from other personality pathology.

The Neurobiological Foundation: Inside the Sadistic Brain

Brain Structure and Sadism

Recent neuroscience research reveals specific neural patterns in individuals with sadistic tendencies.

The Reward System Activation:

When sadists inflict or witness pain, specific brain regions activate:

• Nucleus accumbens (reward processing)
• Ventral striatum (pleasure and reinforcement)
• Amygdala (emotional processing)
• Orbitofrontal cortex (decision-making about rewards)

This activation triggers dopamine release, creating a sensation of pleasure or euphoria. The brain literally rewards sadistic behavior in the same way it rewards natural rewards like food or sex.

Impulsivity and Response Inhibition:

Individuals with high sadism demonstrate:

• Reduced P3 amplitude on Go/No-Go tasks (decreased neural response to inhibitory cues)
• Greater dysfunctional impulsivity
• Weaker response inhibition at a neural level
• Difficulty suppressing sadistic urges when opportunities arise

This suggests sadism involves not just motivation toward cruelty but also diminished ability to inhibit that motivation.

The “Sadistic Neuroplasticity” Phenomenon:

The brain demonstrates remarkable ability to reshape itself through repeated exposure to cruelty. Researchers call this “sadistic neuroplasticity” – the brain’s capacity to fundamentally rewire itself until cruelty becomes rewarding.

With repeated sadistic behaviors:

• Reward pathways strengthen
• Inhibitory pathways weaken
• Pain-infliction becomes increasingly pleasurable
• Neural systems adapt to treat suffering as a reward signal

What Happens During and After Sadistic Acts

The Pleasure-Pain Paradox

A surprising 2023 study examining how sadists feel before, during, and after aggressive acts revealed a counterintuitive pattern.

During the Act:

• Sadistic individuals report significantly greater pleasure
• Positive affect increases during aggression
• The pleasure appears contingent on victim suffering
• Heightened arousal and excitement accompany the act

The Unexpected Aftermath:

Contrary to popular belief:

• After aggression ceases, sadists’ overall mood drops significantly
• They report greater negative emotion post-act than before
• The pleasure rapidly fades once victim suffering stops
• They experience emotional pain following the aggressive act
• They feel worse after the act than they did initially

The Research Conclusion:

“Aggression feels good in the moment but this pleasure quickly fades and is replaced by pain.” This suggests sadists experience a cycle similar to drug addiction – temporary euphoria followed by emotional crash.

Implications for Intervention:

Understanding this pattern suggests intervention possibilities. By helping sadists perceive how their actions will harm them emotionally, or by changing how they perceive victim suffering, the aggression cycle could potentially be interrupted.

The Developmental Origins: How Sadism Forms

Childhood Trauma and Abuse

Research strongly supports childhood trauma, particularly physical abuse, as a pathway to sadistic development.

Physical Abuse and Sadism:

In a study of 54 incarcerated juveniles:

• Expert-rated physical abuse severity was significantly associated with physical sadism
• Expert-rated physical abuse was associated with vicarious sadism (pleasure from others’ suffering even without causing it directly)
• Physical abuse alone didn’t predict sadism in all cases, but when combined with vicarious sadistic traits, it conferred highest risk for non-homicide violence

The Intergenerational Pattern:

Children exposed to violence learn through modeling that pain can lead to pleasure for others. Social learning becomes powerful when children witness that:

• Authority figures inflict pain
• Pain-infliction leads to compliance
• Others’ suffering produces satisfaction

Children learn to model these behaviors as means of gaining power or pleasure.

Role of Childhood Sexual Abuse:

Sexual Sadism Disorder research suggests:

• Sadistic sexual fantasies often trace back to childhood
• Individuals with Sexual Sadism frequently report histories of both sexual and physical childhood abuse
• Abuse appears to shape the specific content and intensity of sadistic fantasies
• Adult sadistic behaviors often represent reenactment or elaboration of childhood experiences

Dehumanization as a Learned Process:

Children who experience abuse learn that:

• Victims are objects, not people
• Others’ feelings don’t matter
• Pain and suffering are normal or justified
• Dominating others is acceptable

This learned dehumanization persists into adulthood and facilitates sadistic behavior by preventing empathic connection with victims.

The Role of Empathy: Why Sadists Don’t Feel What Others Feel

Paradoxical Empathy

One of the most disturbing findings is that sadists actually feel others’ pain more intensely than average, not less.

The Critical Difference:

Most people feel others’ pain and experience distress – their empathic response creates barrier to inflicting suffering.

Sadists also feel others’ pain intensely, but they experience that pain as pleasurable rather than distressing. The empathic response doesn’t inhibit sadism; instead, it fuels it.

How This Develops:

Through combination of:

• Repeated exposure to violence normalizing it
• Learned association between others’ pain and personal pleasure
• Neuroplastic rewiring of reward systems
• Reduced access to compassion through dehumanization

The sadist’s empathy becomes weaponized – they feel what others feel, but instead of motivating compassion, it motivates further cruelty.

The Dark Tetrad Connection: Sadism in Context

Where Sadism Fits

Sadism represents the fourth member of the Dark Tetrad personality constellation, alongside psychopathy, narcissism, and Machiavellianism.

How Sadism Relates to Other Dark Traits:

Psychopathy and Sadism: Strongest relationship among Dark Tetrad traits. Psychopathic coldheartedness particularly predicts sadistic pleasure. All psychopathic components (interpersonal, affective, lifestyle, antisocial) correlate with increased sadism.

Narcissism and Sadism: Moderate to weak relationship. Grandiosity and narcissistic entitlement correlate less strongly with sadism than psychopathy does.

Machiavellianism and Sadism: No significant relationship. Strategic manipulation doesn’t necessarily involve sadistic pleasure-seeking.

Paraphilic Interests: Everyday sadism strongly predicts paraphilic arousal (43.2% of variance explained). Psychopathy more strongly predicts actual paraphilic behavior than sexual arousal.

The Key Insight: Sadism appears in its purest form as a distinct desire for others’ suffering, independent from other dark traits’ motivations of power, status, or material gain.

The Torture Psychology: Extending Sadism to Systemic Cruelty

Beyond Individual Sadism

The psychology of organized torture extends sadistic impulses into systematic frameworks of control.

Why Authority Figures Torture:

Medieval and modern torture practices reveal several psychological mechanisms:

Power Demonstration: Torture serves as brutal reminder of power held by authorities. It displays dominance and capacity for inflicting suffering.

Control Through Fear: Creating environment of constant threat ensures compliance. “Debility, dependency, and dread” become systematic strategies to reduce victims to compliance.

Normalization of Cruelty: When torture becomes institutionalized, societies become desensitized. Public spectacles make cruelty routine and entertainment.

Rationalization: Authorities convince themselves torture is “necessary” for maintaining order. Victims become deserving of suffering through dehumanization.

Psychological Torture Components:

Beyond physical methods, psychological torture involves:

• Absolute powerlessness
• Reduction of victim to “animal, a body without will”
• Threats preceding actual torture
• Environmental monopolization (controlling all sensory input)
• Social isolation and confinement
• Sleep deprivation and exhaustion

These psychological methods often inflict as much damage as physical torture.

The Paradox: Those administering torture often frame themselves as serving justice, maintaining order, or protecting society. This rationalization allows torturers to avoid acknowledging their own sadistic pleasure.

Sadism in “Everyday” Contexts: The Spectrum of Cruelty

Sadism Isn’t Rare

Contrary to assumption that sadism exists only in violent criminals, research reveals it manifests throughout society.

Everyday Manifestations:

Internet Trolls: Deliberately provoke and upset others for entertainment, investing time and effort in others’ distress

School Bullies: Go beyond dominance to actively engineer suffering, finding pleasure in victims’ pain

Video Game “Griefers”: Players who intentionally ruin others’ gaming experience, seemingly deriving pleasure from ruining enjoyment

Workplace Sadists: Supervisors who exercise unnecessary cruelty over subordinates, enjoying power through suffering

Social Media Cruelty: Piling on during public shaming, finding entertainment in others’ humiliation

Animal Abuse: Inflicting pain on defenseless creatures for gratification

The Research on Everyday Sadists:

• More common than expected in general population
• Score high on sadism scales
• Actively choose to harm innocent targets
• Willingly expend extra effort to cause suffering
• Demonstrate reduced empathy
• Show pleasure during others’ pain
• Often feel remorse afterward when pleasure fades

What Makes It Sadism vs. Aggression:

Key distinguishing feature: willingness to sacrifice personal gain simply to cause pain. In one study, sadists chose to intensify blasts of white noise directed at an innocent opponent when they realized the opponent wouldn’t fight back.

This isn’t self-defense or dominance-seeking. It’s pure pleasure-motivated suffering.

The Dark Side of Paraphilias: Sexual Sadism and Serial Murder

The Connection Between Sadism and Sexual Deviance

Research reveals strong relationship between sadistic traits and paraphilic interests, particularly in violent offenders.

Sexual Sadism in Serial Killers:

• Sexual Sadism extremely rare (1-2%) in general population
• Highly prevalent in serial killers and sexual murderers
• Often associated with Antisocial Personality Disorder
• May lead to serious injury or death of victims
• Typically involves fantasies of total dominance or control
• Often sadistic fantasies present from childhood

The Escalation Pattern:

• Begins with sadistic fantasies in childhood
• Fantasies typically intensify during adolescence
• Acts increase in severity over lifespan
• Often chronic and progressive course
• May eventually escalate to murder

Why Sadism Drives Sexual Murder:

Sexual arousal becomes conditioned to suffering. Through repeated fantasy and eventual behavioral enactment:

• Pain infliction becomes sexually arousing
• Victim suffering enhances sexual pleasure
• Violence becomes integrated into sexual response
• Sadism and sexuality become neurologically intertwined

Once established, this conditioning is remarkably difficult to extinguish.

Why Some People Become Sadists: The Etiology Question

Multiple Pathways

No single cause explains sadism’s development. Rather, multiple factors converge:

1. Neurobiological Factors

• Differences in dopamine reward system sensitivity
• Reduced amygdala responsivity to others’ distress
• Diminished prefrontal-limbic connectivity for impulse inhibition
• Possible genetic predisposition to low empathy

2. Early Trauma and Abuse

• Physical abuse teaching pain leads to dominance
• Sexual abuse conditioning sexual response to violence
• Witnessed violence normalizing cruelty
• Lack of secure attachment reducing empathy development

3. Learned Associations

• Repeated pairing of suffering with pleasure
• Observation of others enjoying cruelty
• Social reinforcement for aggressive behavior
• Desensitization through exposure

4. Dehumanization Processes

• Viewing certain groups as less human
• Rationalization that victims “deserve” suffering
• Moral disengagement from consequences
• Separation of victims from in-group membership

5. Environmental Factors

• Cultures normalizing violence
• Authority structures modeling cruelty
• Exposure to violent media
• Peer groups reinforcing sadistic behavior

The Treatment Challenge: Can Sadism Be Changed?

Current Reality

Unlike some personality disorders, sadism remains remarkably resistant to treatment.

Why Treatment Fails:

• Sadists don’t experience suffering as problematic
• They lack motivation for change
• Treatment could make them more sophisticated abusers
• Core reward systems are deeply ingrained
• No pharmacological intervention specifically targets sadism

Emerging Approaches:

Impulse Control Training: Research on response inhibition suggests potential utility of interventions strengthening inhibitory control.

Affect-Based Intervention: Understanding that sadists feel negative affect after cruelty suggests possibility of helping them recognize and amplify this natural negative consequence.

Victim-Focused Approach: Helping sadists perceive victims’ actual suffering more accurately – and potentially increasing their awareness of negative consequences for themselves.

Early Intervention: Prevention in childhood may be more promising than treatment in adulthood. Interventions addressing callous-unemotional traits and trauma response show greater efficacy.

Realistic Assessment

Current interventions show limited efficacy with established sadism. Management typically focuses on:

• Containment rather than cure
• Incapacitation through incarceration
• Surveillance to prevent reoffending
• Environmental control to limit victim access

Conclusion: Understanding the Sadistic Mind

Sadism represents a profound deviation from typical human moral functioning. While most people feel others’ pain and experience distress when causing suffering, sadists either lack this empathic response or experience pain as pleasurable.

Key findings:

Sadism is common than expected: Not limited to violent criminals but manifests across society in various forms

Sadism differs from psychopathy: While related, sadism is distinct in its focus on others’ suffering as intrinsically rewarding

Sadism has multiple origins: Neurobiological factors, childhood trauma, learned associations, and environmental influences all contribute

The brain literally rewards cruelty: Through dopamine release and neuroplastic rewiring, sadistic behavior becomes rewarding

Sadism creates an addiction cycle: Pleasure during acts, remorse after, then craving for next opportunity – similar to substance addiction

Current treatments are limited: Sadism remains remarkably resistant to intervention, suggesting prevention and containment as primary strategies

Understanding sadism matters: For identifying at-risk individuals, developing interventions, understanding serial killers, and recognizing cruelty in everyday contexts

The Psychology of sadism represents one of psychology’s darkest puzzles – how humans can become wired to find pleasure in others’ suffering. Understanding this psychology doesn’t excuse sadistic cruelty but rather illuminates the pathways by which some humans become capable of inflicting precisely the kind of suffering most people find abhorrent.

• Book of the Year

•